...
- ~buckeyeskeeve@idp.protectnetwork.org: On the call we suggested that one or more of the choices be a full-frame login process instead of a popup.
- ~buckeyeskeeve@idp.protectnetwork.org: Too many initial choices, probably more likely to be a small set of big players and the MyNCBI choice.
- ~buckeyeskeeve@idp.protectnetwork.org: We probably need some kind of "Help" or "What is this?" link on the pop up to give people some exposition.
- ~buckeyeskeeve@idp.protectnetwork.org: I'd suggest adding at least a couple of IdP choices that don't show up as "preferred" icons but will show up if you start typing them (maybe there are now? obviously this is a function of knowing the options exist).
- ~buckeyeskeeve@idp.protectnetwork.org: There's nothing on the various login forms that references back to the site requesting the login. That's something we're building into the new Shibboleth work being done.
- ~buckeyeskeeve@idp.protectnetwork.org: There ought to be a "see all choices" capability to break out of the captive list. Not clear whether a drop down or just actual presentation of a list is best. This leads into....
- ~buckeyeskeeve@idp.protectnetwork.org: Accessibility. Not so much a mockup issue, but that will be a major concern for anything we do with it and this might need to be noted to any testers, that it's not in that state yet. For current purposes, I think the point to be made is we should ensure anything mocked up could be rendered in an accessible fashion for screen readers and such.
- Paul Trevithick: The Oauth/permissioning third window is present in the Google account-button flow but is missing from the Yahoo, PayPal and MSFT Live flows.
- Paul Trevithick: Although we've been focusing on the unmodified browser cases, our goal is that the "with active client" UI looks remarkably similar/consistent although in ths case rendered by the active client instead of the RP. So when we look at the popup from the point of view of it being a prototype active client UI we immediately see that the account buttons are much smaller than the IMI i-card images, and they have a different aspect ratio. The account button that starts off being simply the Equifax logo must somehow morph into an account button that represents the card that you downloaded when you became an active client user. Further, we need to handle the case where more than one Equifax card may be displayed--and thus they need to be distinguishable. One possible approach might be for the account buttons to inherit some kind of color/texture or sub-title wording from the information card image that they represent and in addition, if you hover over the account-button it explodes into the full image of the i-card.
Feedback on Version 2
Based on the ULX call of February 24th, we would at least like to make the following changes to version 2:
...