Date
Oct 28, 2013, in London
Attendees
(if this meeting needed a quorum it had one )
Mark Lizar (Unlicensed)
Reuben Binns -
- Valentino Sparta
- Ivan Amaya
- Par Lannero
- Innes ? Walker
- Iain Henderson
- Norman Sadeh-Koniecpol
Jan Shallaboeck
Goals
- First Physical Open Notice meeting -
- Objective is to start collaborating -
- update/present on projects -
- Discuss Next Steps
Discussion Items
Time | Item | Who | Presentation Link Slides | Notes | Discussion |
---|
30min | Presentation on the Consent Tag | Mark Lizar | https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/1959097/Open%20Notice/On-Consent%20Tag%20Intro-28-10-2013.pdf | - Opened with the question: what is Open Notice?
- Joe Andrieu presented a version of the Open Notice posted in(found in the Schema Sandbox on the wiki) that . This version of Open Notice was not consent specific. Rather for each web page was not consent specific and used for each web page. In this context a consent receipt would be a specific instance of an Open Notice,
- In this context the Consent Receipt is a
- Mark talked about Discovery/Publishing of the consent receipt.
- Various notice discovery options presented
- The provision of a consent receipt at the point of consent is the primary way of discovery for the consent tag.
- Wether this works for all open notices is up for debate, in fact a publishing methods of consent tags can themselves be used to open the notice of the website, and be published with the various discovery options presented in the presentation
- Consent tag is required infrastructure that is missing and needed for compliance to solve many issues regulators have - illustrated EU law and talked about NSTIC - US Gov - Hypothesis for Discovery is that Adoption will be required with new EU laws. Discovery will be at the point of consent.
| We discussed the consent tag, Par question the use of the word tag. It was agreed that the consent tag is really more of a digital consent transaction receipt. Valentino does a lot of work crowdsourcing and tagging legal resources and there is a distinct difference between what is common thought of as tagging and what we are proposing with the 'Consent Tag" So we are now changing this to 'Consent Transaction Receipt/Token'. This term may change again but for now it closer to accurately representing the effort. (personally I am leaning towards Consent Transaction Token (CTT). Its more functional description than conceptual) |
30 Min | Presentation on Common Terms | Par Lannero | http://commonterms.net/opennoticemeet131028.pdf | - Par presented on Common Terms, illustrating how signs are very important and used to summarise and make useful policy.
- Illustrated a concentrated study of common elements of policy and broke these down to an easy category
- Developed a process for companies to go through to link policy to these categories
| - Lots of discussion about categories and different ways to display data found in terms, with Hugo and (TOS;Dr).
- Valentino suggested that he can help with the Common Terms project and will send Par an email to this regard
- Hugo and Par to discuss and look at common categories
|
30 Min | Presentation on Notice From Data Controllers Register | Reuben Bins | | - Presented his research on purpose in data protection
- collected data base of data protection registrations and listed purposes by type
- Illustrated a dynamic diagram for
- Interesting to see what is used for purpose now and how relevant (or not) it is to current environment of consent online
| |
30 Min | Presentation - Usable Privacy Project | Norma Sadeh | Remote VideoParticipation | - Work comes from privcy preference modelling, location sharing privacy prefs, mobile app for privacy prefs,
people care about limited number of issues - small clusters who have like-minded preferences. - Work includes
- personalising discloresdisclosures
- nutrition labels, privacy icons, etc.
- NLP and machine-learning
- Parsing and statistical linguistic analysis techniques - to auto extract features of policies. Not to fully automate, (impossible) but to speed up what can be accomplished with crowd-sourcing. The ability to identify a small number of silences.
- E.g. privacychoice. Go beyond keywords.
- Amazon mechanical turk - to get quality annotations.
- Identify pertinent fragments of texts - extract answers.
- Formal methods side - build on what extracted from policies. formal models of privacy policies
- Joel Reidenberg working on the legal side, with aleecia mcdonald, lorrie cranor.
- Updating the sweeping techniques. GPEN sweep.
- Joel Reidneberg - ask about the raw data from GPEN.
Playing with different ways of asking questions to users. Presentations. funded by the national science foundation (US) - grouping and packaging privacy preferences
- done a lot of work in nutrition labels
- privacy icons
- Natural Language Processing and Machine Learning
|
...
- Norman Sadeh explained that the project is starting and that they are reviewing applications from post graduates to start in January
- Will post a post grad to the list at this point
- Available via email and very much interested in collaborating where and when possible
|
Topics for discussion
- Joint funding proposals
- we discussed with Jan about looking for EU funding calls
- Norman Sadeh mentioned that the he was open to collaborating with a sister project
- Ways we collaborate
- The Open Notice Google List
- We decided to use if for general discussion and use the WG list for work based discussion
- What to do next
- will look into categories
- funding for Open Notice joint collaboration
- Open Notice Website
Action Items
...
- Everyone: Introduce self on WG-InfoSharing
...
Expand the wiki.
Par's colleague to update the website.
Read funding draft application - decide if you want to be a partner.
R:.
Action Items
- & Expand Wiki in your area of interest
- Mark Lizar (Unlicensed) to compile notes
- Mark start a page for categories
- Propose funding ideas (if you have them)
- Par - Open Notice Website Update
- Par - Cookie Policy Use Case for Consent Tags
- Reuben - Ask about if Uni Southampton can be trustee for funding
- Valentino send Par email on Common Terms
- J-S: find out about new EU funding stream.