...
This document records the User-Managed Access (UMA) Work Group's disposition of comments received during the since the beginning of the May-July 2017 Public Comment and IPR Review period for the UMA V2.0 Draft Recommendations.
...
Comment Reference | Specification Reference(s) | Editorial/ Technical | Disposition | Report Out | Notes | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
#326 | Grant Sec 1.3 | Editorial | Commit | Editorial improvement to a spec definition suggested; discussed by several WG participants and consensus rapidly gained. | ||
#327 | Grant Sec 3.3.6 | Editorial | Commit | Simple editorial wording fix suggested; discussed by several WG participants and consensus rapidly gained. | ||
#328 | Grant Sec 3.3.4 | Editorial | Commit | Interpretation issue raised; discussed thoroughly by the WG and an editorial enhancement removing ambiguity adopted by the WG. | ||
#329 | Grant 7.4.1 | Editorial | Commit | Incorrect cross-reference noted; fix applied without WG intervention required. | ||
#330 | FedAuthz Sec 9.2 | Editorial | No change | Simple editorial correction suggested; fix overcome by events (#334). | ||
#331 | FedAuthz Sec 9.3 | Editorial | Commit | Simple editorial correction suggested; fix applied without WG intervention required. | ||
#332 | Grant (various) | Editorial | No change | Interpretation question raised; WG decided to keep the existing wording. | ||
#333 | Grant Sec 3.3.6 | Editorial | Commit | Simple editorial correction requested; fix applied without WG intervention required. | ||
#334 | FedAuthz Sec 1, FedAuthz Sec 9.2 | Editorial | Commit | Interpretation issue raised; discussed thoroughly by the WG and an editorial resolution adopted by the WG involving removal of text. | ||
#335a | Grant (various), FedAuthz (various) | Editorial | No change | Yes | Editorial improvement requested; editor recommended no change. | |
#335b | Grant (various), FedAuthz (various) | Editorial | Commit | Yes | Editorial improvements requested; small edits applied without WG intervention required. | |
#335c | Grant Sec 1.3 | Editorial | tbs | Yes | Editorial improvement to diagram(s) requested; tbs | |
#335d | Grant Sec 1.3 | Editorial | tbs | Yes | Editorial improvement to diagram(s) requested; tbs | |
#336 | FedAuthz Sec 5.1 | Editorial | Commit | Editorial improvement requested; discussed by several WG participants and consensus rapidly gained. | ||
#337a | FedAuthz Sec 5.1.1 | Editorial | Commit | Clarification requested; WG determined an editorial improvement. | ||
#337b | Grant Sec 3.3.3 | Editorial | Commit | Clarification requested; WG determined an editorial improvement. | ||
#337c,d | Grant Sec 2, Grant Sec 3.3.2, Grant new Sec 7.3 | Technical | Commit | Request for new mechanism for dynamic client registration mechanism and clarity; WG agreed. Mechanism requires a registration request to IANA. | ||
#337e | Grant Sec 3.3.3 | Editorial | Commit | Simple editorial correction requested; fix applied without WG intervention required. | ||
#337f | Grant Sec 3.3.4 | Editorial | tbs | Clarification requested; tbs | ||
#337g | Grant (various) | Editorial | Commit | Additional security considerations requested; WG agreed to add a form of security considerations that gives more discretion to the authorization server than was requested. | (Public Comment/IPR Period closed)||
#338 | FedAuthz Sec 3.2.1 | Editorial | Commit | Simple typo correction requested; typo fixed without WG intervention required. | ||
#339 | FedAuthz Sec 4.1 | Editorial | Commit | Clarification requested; WG confirmed the correct interpretation and clarification text. | ||
#340 | Grant Sec 3.3.6 | Editorial | Commit, commit | Clarification requested; WG confirmed the correct interpretation and clarification text. | ||
#341 | Grant Sec 3.3.6, Sec 5.6 | Technical | Commit | Change requested; WG made a different change, adding an optional new feature. | ||
#342 | ||||||
#343 | Grant Sec 3.3.6 | Editorial | Commit | Clarification requested; WG confirmed the correct interpretation and clarification text. | ||
#344 | Grant Sec 3.3.6 | Editorial | Commit | Clarification requested; WG confirmed the correct interpretation and clarification text. | ||
#345 | Grant Sec 3.3.6 | Editorial | Commit | Clarification requested; WG confirmed the correct interpretation and clarification text. | ||
#346 | Grant Sec 3.3.4 | Editorial | No change | Clarification requested; commenter decided to close own issue without action | ||
#347 | ||||||
#348 | ||||||
#349 | ||||||
#350 | Grant Sec 3.3.4 | Editorial | Commit | Yes | Clarification requested; WG confirmed the correct interpretation and clarification text. | |
#351 | FedAuthz (various) | Editorial | Commit | Variety of editorial comments, typo corrections, and the like made; implemented without WG intervention required. Note that the original form of the text in Sec 3.2, since corrected, could have led implementers astray, implying that a field was required when it was clear in a different context (Sec 3.2.4) that the field would not appear. | ||
#352 | FedAuthz Sec 1.4.1, Sec 1.5 | Editorial | Commit | Change requested; WG made some clarifications instead. |