2018-11-01 Meeting Notes

Owned by Former user (Deleted)
Last updated: Jan 16, 2019


Attendees

Voting participants: Ken Dagg; Scott Shorter; Mark Hapner; Andrew Hughes, JJ Harkema 

Non-voting participants: Roger Quint and SATO Hiroyuki

Staff: Ruth Puente and Colin Wallis 

Quorum: 5 of 8. There was quorum.


Agenda


  1. Administration:
    1. Roll Call
    2. Agenda Confirmation
    3. Action Item Review: action item list
    4. Minutes Approval: 2018-09-13 Meeting Notes
    5. Staff reports and updates - Keeping up with Kantara
    6. LC reports and updates
    7. Call for Tweet-worthy items to feed (@KantaraNews or #kantara)
  2. Discussion

a. Approve Revised IAF Overview (IAF 1000) v2.3 (attached). So far we have received comments on the Overview document suggesting changes to the Notice text as this is not a specification and that the file name sent to the IAWG mailing list is not correct, it should be 2.3.

b. Confirm IAWG Charter and Leadership.

c. Developing NIST 800-63-3 Implementation Guidance and Updates to KI SAC: Status of revised IAF 1410, 1430 and 1440.


Minutes approval

2018-09-13 Meeting Notes were approved by motion. 


Updates 

  • GSA is having problems with funding, and the oversight of the TFS Program seem to be going away. The federal agencies would make the determination to direct the CSPs to switch to 63-3. 
  • Keep up with Kantara - October 2018 (Kantara partner of go e-ID.AS;  ISO SC27 Working Group 5)
  • Andrew commented that the Identity Proofing and Verification Use Cases Discussion Group was created to gather use cases from organizations that perform or require identity assurance. The DG will create a Report containing the use cases, which will be processed into a format suitable for contribution into the ISO SC 27/WG 5 Study Period to collect and document Use Cases for an Identity Assurance Framework.


Confirm IAWG Charter and Leadership

  • Ken made a review of IAWG charter and believes there is no need of updates.
  • Ken expressed its desire to continue as Chair and Scott as Vice-Chair. 

Approval of IAWG Charter: The IAWG Charter was approved by motion. 

Approval of Leadership: The Chair, Ken Dagg, and Vice-Chair, Scott Shorter, were confirmed by motion. 


Revised IAF Overview (IAF 1000) v2.3 

  • Ken has received 3 comments (changes to the Notice text; version number; and type of document) but he suggests to make another comment cycle to get more feedback from stakeholders, in particular from the CSPs. 
  • IAWG agreed to set up a new 2 week comment cycle. Ken asked Ruth and Colin to contact the CSPs and request feedback on the revised Overview document. 

Status of revised IAF 1410, 1430 and 1440

  • The IAWG has updated the Service Assessment Criteria (SAC) in response to the three memos containing implementation guidance with respect to interpreting the NIST 800-63-3 requirements at AL2 that were issued in the summer. The changes help explain and make easier the existing assessment criteria.

  • The 3 documents were approved by All Member Ballot, which closed on October 27th, and will be published in the IAF Controlling Docs.