Attendees:
Voting participants: Ken Dagg, Tom Jones, Mark Hapner, Mark King, Martin Smith
Non participants: Sarah Chu, Easy Dynamics (representing JJ Harkema)
Kantara staff: Colin Wallis and Ruth Puente
Quorum: As of 2019-12-19, quorum is 3 of 5. There was quorum
Agenda
Administration:
- Roll Call
- Agenda Confirmation
- Action Item Review: action item list
- Minutes approval 2020-07-09 Draft Minutes
- Staff reports and updates - Director's Corner and Keeping up with the Kantarians
- LC reports and updates
- Call for Tweet-worthy items to feed (@KantaraNews
Discussion
a. Comments on 800-63-3 to ultimately lead to Revision 4.
b. Update on xAL3 Sub-group, which is preparing criteria for 63B at AAL3 and 63C at FAL3.
3. Any Other Business
Minutes Approval
2020-07-09 Minutes were approved by motion. Moved: Mark Hapner Seconded: Martin Smith. Unanimous Approval.
Updates
- Australian (ATO) and New Zealand (DIA) governments renewed their Kantara membership.
- Kantara Summer Webinars:
1) What does it take to be Approved as NIST 800-63-3 conformant? 2020-07-15; recording and slides available at: https://kantarainitiative.org/download/what-does-it-take-to-be-approved-as-nist-800-63-3-conformant/
2) UMA 21st century health information interoperability + user control will take place on 2020-07-22; recording and slides will be posted here: https://kantarainitiative.org/download/uma-21st-century-health-information-interoperability-user-control/
- eGov WG was archived.
Update on xAL3 Sub-group
- IAL3 was approved by IAWG on 2020-07-09.
- Sub-group is working on AAL3 and FAL3 criteria and plan to finish at the end of the month. Next steps: send the drafts for IAWG review and approval.
- FAL2 is under Public Comment and IPR Review until July 24th.
- It is estimated that the xAL3s would be ready for assessment by end of September.
Gather comments for revisions to SP 800-63-3 to ultimately lead to Revision 4
- Ken sent the instructions to IAWG mailing list on how to comment and make suggestions on 800-63-3, including the PDFs with line numbers.
He stressed that the commenters should use the following structure to submit comments:
- Volume Identifier (All, Overview, A, B or C)
- Section Identifier (Number AND Name)
- Sub-Section Identifier (Number AND Name)
- Line number
- Comment: Be as specific as possible. If relevant, provide references to other jurisdictions to justify your comment.
- Suggested Revision: Provide suggested text if possible.
- Please use the PDFs with line numbers as reference for your comments.
- Ken will compile all comments into a list for discussion by IAWG. The plan is to schedule two IAWG meetings (July 30th and August 6th) to reach consensus prior to NIST’s August 10th submission deadline.
AoB
- Mark King commented about a Jerry Fishenden paper 'Federated Identity for Access to UK Public Services: 1997–2020' that may be of IAWG interest: https://ntouk.files.wordpress.com/2020/06/federated-identity-for-access-to-uk-public-services-1997-2020-jerry-fishenden-1.pdf. Moreover, he mentioned that a British Standard, 'BS 8626 Design and operation of online user identification systems – Code of practice' is available for public comment until August 31st, available at the BSI website here: https://standardsdevelopment.bsigroup.com/projects/2018-01712#/section. He stressed that it is only guidance; he is preparing comments in relation to the significant gaps he founded on the standard.