/
2024-07-11 IAWG Meeting Notes

2024-07-11 IAWG Meeting Notes

Owned by Amanda, created
Last updated: Aug 07, 2024
6 min read

Meeting Status Metadata

Quorum

quorate

Notes-Status

approved

Approved-Link

2024-07-25 IAWG Meeting Notes

The meeting status metadata table is used for summary reports - copy the status macros from the table in these instructions:

Quorum: quorate not quorate

Notes-Status: drafting Ready for review approved

Approved-Link: Insert a link to the Meeting Notes page holding the approval decision for this notes page

Agenda

  1. Administration:

  1. IAWG Actions/Reminders/Updates:

    • Proposed Meeting Cadence for June/Extended Summer*

      • July 11, July 25

      • August 8, August 22

      • *If rev.4 is released, this cadence will be updated 

  2. ISO 17065 Discussion Items

  3. Group Discussion:  

    • NIST's 63B Supplement for Syncable Authenticators 

      •  What changes are required? What additional criteria is needed in the existing framework to demonstrate conformity?

    • Potential Criteria Updates

      • Discussion: re: 63B#1340, 63A#0130 b) (Jimmy Jung’s email on May 28th),  and  63B#0120. Led by Jimmy.

    • ARB comment on potential bug in 63A#0510 criteria (Lynzie)

      • Talks about biometric performance requirements which is more about measuring algorithmic performance and not human performance. If using a human, this cannot be done.

      • #0510 references 63B authentication criteria and authentication doesn’t recognize human verification of the biometric against some portrait or reference biometric. The 63B criteria is only applicable to automated biometric systems.

  4. Any Other Business

 

 Attendees

  • Roll call, determination of quorum. The meeting was quorate and called to order.

    • Voting: Andrew Hughes, Jimmy Jung, Mark King, Yehoshua Silverstein, Mike Magrath, Scott Jones, Vladimir Stojkovski, Richard Wilsher

    • NonVoting: Eric Thompson, Tim Anderson, Nathan Faut

    • Guests: Lisa Balzerit

    • Staff: Kay Chopard, David Nutbrown, James Keenan

Quorum determination

Meeting is quorate when 50% + 1 of voting participants attend

There are <<8>> voters as of <<2024-07-10>>

 

Approval of Prior Minutes

Motion to approve meeting minutes listed below: Motion passes.

Moved by: Jimmy Jung and Andrew Hughes

Seconded by: Mark King

Link to draft minutes and outcome

Discussion

Link to draft minutes and outcome

Discussion

2024.06.27 Minutes DRAFT

 

 Discussion topics

Time

Item

Presenter

Notes

Time

Item

Presenter

Notes

 

Kantara Updates

Kay/Auditors

  • Kay was in attendance at many conferences.

  • UK Staff expanded with David and James (auditors), but they will also provide technical support to Lynzie/US Assurance program as that program has grown.

  • 17065 Desk Audit-This was completed as scheduled.  Report is forthcoming, once it is received, an update will be provided.

 

NIST's 63B Supplement for Syncable Authenticators

Andrew Hughes + Group

  • What changes are required? What additional criteria is needed in the existing framework to demonstrate conformity?

  • Seeking an action to come out of this.

  • Hughes: Seems that most of the new requirements focus on the federal delivery of authenticators to internal employees/contractors of the agency, with little to no requirements to the user end.

  • Jimmy: Believes it impacts 63B the most (where we don’t sync/clone).  This seems to be aimed at passkeys (if they are allowed from the relying party/tied to a browser).  When an individual registers with a site and creates a passkey, the relying party has no ability to cons