2025-03-27 IAWG Meeting Notes

Meeting Status Metadata

Quorum	quorate
Notes-Status	approved
Approved-Link	2025-04-10 IAWG Meeting Notes

The meeting status metadata table is used for summary reports - copy the status macros from the table in these instructions:

Quorum: quorate not quorate

Notes-Status: drafting Ready for review approved

Approved-Link: Insert a link to the Meeting Notes page holding the approval decision for this notes page

Agenda

DRAFT 01.23.2025

Administration:

Roll call, determination of quorum.
Minutes approval
- Deferred
Kantara Updates
Assurance Updates

IAWG Actions/Reminders/Updates:
Group Discussion:

Action item list and Issue tracker review

Attendees

Voting Participants

Donald, India	GSA
Hughes, Andrew	FaceTec	Present
Jung, Jimmy	Slandala	Present
Magrath, Michael	Easy Dynamics	Present
Silberstein, Yehoshua	Notarize	Present
Stojkovski, Vladimir	CLEAR
Wilsher, Richard	Zygma Inc.	Present

Nonvoting:

Brown, Wendy	FPKI	Present
Bachenheimer, Dan	Accenture	Present
Brown, Cynetheia	FPKI	Present
Anderson, Tim	ID. me	Present
Aronson, Marc		Present
King, Mark		Present

Staff:

Buttle, Carol	Kantara	Present
Chopard, Kay	Kantara	Present

Guests:

Quorum determination

Meeting is quorate when 50% + 1 of voting participants attend

There are 7 voters as of 2025-03-27

Approval of Prior Minutes

Motion to approve meeting minutes listed below:

Moved by:

Seconded by:

<< Defer to next meeting>>

Discussion topics

LINKS TO THE ISSUES TRACKER DATABASE ADDED 2025-07-17 BY A. HUGHES

Time	Item	Presenter	Notes

Time

Item

Presenter

Notes

US Assurance Program updates

Kay/Carol

Applications are spinning up after a slow start to the year, including non-US companies wanting to do US business

General issues

All

YS: Some CSPs consider that the NIST 800-63 requirements are not really structurally built to meet the needs of “current” service provider implementations. Today, CSPs sub-contract many functions - and this is hard to capture and ends up in increased complexity.
Industry input would be useful - to see if there’s an improvement to be had to better align to actual implementations?
An example: GSA has internal forms to determine which services are offered by which applicants to the GSA SIN
IAWG must be clear about approach and scope - is it time to break away from strict 800-63 organization? or is it time to do a more broadly applicable set of requirements?
This could be an opportunity to engage a broader range of stakeholders - this could be a significant shift so we want to be sure that we are making sound decisions.
To be continued…

https://kantara.atlassian.net/wiki/spaces/undefined/database/1097334791?entryId=d974c535-930c-4fe4-8bef-18b559f0429e

Kantara staff to update 63A#0680 to "Withdrawn - this referenced biometrics used as an authentication factor, not in the identity proofing process"

https://kantara.atlassian.net/wiki/spaces/undefined/database/1097334791?entryId=f1e050e6-5cea-418a-ac3d-1ee69f698eb1

Kantara staff to update the label OPB#0490 in the OP_SAC which is repeated 4 times, to OPB#0490 and OPB#0500 as indicated in the attached PDF.

https://kantara.atlassian.net/wiki/spaces/undefined/database/1097334791?entryId=3b92518e-551b-4269-90b9-88019c5accfb

Kantara staff to change 63A-T5-3#strg FROM:
"biometric comparison of the applicant to the identity evidence. Biometric comparison performed remotely SHALL adhere to all criteria 63A#0620 to 63A#0680 inclusive."
TO:
"biometric comparison of the applicant to the strongest piece of identity evidence provided to support the claimed identity. Biometric comparison performed remotely SHALL adhere to all criteria 63A#0620 to 63A#0680 inclusive."

https://kantara.atlassian.net/wiki/spaces/undefined/database/1097334791?entryId=88d14554-d238-4c9b-b868-22a3a9092c37

Tim Anderson to gather proposals for discussion in a future meeting

https://kantara.atlassian.net/wiki/spaces/undefined/database/1097334791?entryId=f2c38a03-decb-4c19-b9d5-70af457b90ae

Open Action items

Action items may be created inline on any page. This block shows all open action items from all meeting notes.