2024-03-20 Meeting notes

 


Date

Mar 20, 2024

Attendees

See the Participant roster

Voting (3 of 6 required for quorum)

Participant

Attending

Participant

Attending

1

Chaudhury, Atef

 

2

Jones, Thomas

Y

3

Krishnaraj, Venkat

 

4

Thoma, Andreas

Y

5

Wunderlich, John

Y

6

Williams, Christopher

Y

Non-Voting

Participant

Attending

Participant

Attending

1

Auld, Lorrayne

 

2

Aronson Mark

 

3

Balfanz, Dirk

 

4

Brudnicki, David

 

5

D'Agostino, Salvatore

 

6

Davis, Peter

 

7

Dowtin, Jazzmine

 

8

Dutta, Tim

 

9

Flanagan, Heather

 

10

Fleenor, Judith

 

11

Glasscock, Amy

 

12

Graaf, Irene

Y

13

Gropper, Adrian

 

14

Hodges, Gail

 

15

Hughes, Andrew

 

16

Jordaan, Loffie

 

17

LeVasseur, Lisa

 

18

Lopez, Cristina Timon

 

19

Pasquale, Jim

 

20

Snell, Oliver

 

21

Stowell, Therese

 

22

Sutor, Hannah

 

23

Tamanini, Greg

 

24

Vachino, Maria

 

25

Whysel, Noreen

 

Goals

  • Review process for requirement creation and review

  • Begin work on 1.1 requirement

Discussion items (AKA Agenda)

Time

Item

Who

Notes

 

 

Time

Item

Who

Notes

 

 

5 min.

  • Start the meeting.

  • Call to order @ 14:07

  • Approve minute

  • Approve agenda

@John Wunderlich

Called to order: 14:07

Quorum reached: Yes

Minutes to approve: Yes

https://kantara.atlassian.net/wiki/spaces/PEMCP/pages/392790047

 

 

 

Open Tasks Review

All

Link to Recommendations (Commenter Link): Recommendations for Privacy Enhancing Mobile Credentials

 

 

 

Review definition of transaction

@John Wunderlich

Added a definition of transaction for review.

 

Group discussed the definition of a Transaction.

Discussion of presentation of data vs. presentation of a mobile credential

Group agreed to current definition in working form and will revisit if contradictions arise.

 

 

 

Follow up on Requirement 1.4 Selected Data Release (Providers)

@John Wunderlich

Requirement 1.4 Selected Data Release (Verifiers) has been moved to be 4.3 Minimal Data Request (Verifiers) which looks a lot like 4.2 Minimum Data for transaction. It may be the case that these are duplicative and can be merged. Open for discussion now or when we get to the section on Data Minimization.

 

Discussed the combination of 4.2 and 4.3, group decided these are distinct requirements. Focus on adjusting language to clearly identify the intent of 4.2 to focus on pre-transaction data planning.

 

 

 

 

 

All

1.4 was confirmed to be correctly scoped as a selective data release requirement.

Irene will follow-up with a framing paragraph for Sec. 1

@Christopher Williams will write a 1.5 requirement on engagement
@John Wunderlich will write a framing paragraph for Sec. 2

 

 

14:52

 

Adjourn

 

 

 

Next meeting

Mar 27, 2024

Action items