UMA telecon 2011-06-16

Date and Time

WG telecon on Thursday, 16 Jun 2011, at 9-10:30am PT (time chart) – Eve regrets; Maciej to chair and record minutes
- Skype line "C": +9900827042954214
- US: +1-201-793-9022 (other int'l numbers) | Room Code: 295-4214

Agenda

Roll call
Approve minutes of 2011-06-02 and 2011-06-09 meetings
Action item review
Confirm ad hoc meeting dates if possible
Updates from the wider UMA world: SMARTam.net, etc.
Protocol revisions: core spec
- Open issues
- Fill in missing bits
- Interface between UMA and trusted claims (OpenID Connect)
Schedule gut check: can we submit by 30 Jun if not 24 Jun?
AOB

Attendees

As of 2 Jun 2011 (pre-mtg), quorum is 6 of 11.

Catalano, Domenico
Hardjono, Thomas
Machulak, Maciej
Moren, Lukasz
Wolniak, Maciej
Wray, Frank

Non-voting:

Brennan, Joni
Nederkoorn, Cordny

Minutes

Roll call

Quorum was reached.

Approve minutes of 2011-06-02 and 2011-06-09 meetingh3

Minutes of 2011-06-02 and 2011-06-09 approved.

Action items

Frank to send an email to the group regarding discovery of hData, service providers - is that a part of UMA or should this be separate? Everyone is encouraged to look at the email and provide input in the etherpad.

Confirm ad hoc meeting dates

The ad hoc meeting (in addition to the regular Thursday meeting) is Wednesday, June 22, at 7am PT / 10am ET / 3pm UK.

Protocol revisions: core spec

Thomas discusses the current revision of the specification. There will be a new section introduced. Discussion on how the host authenticates to the AM. Thomas plans to add more text to more text to section 2.2. Now there are issues numbered at the back (and included in the text for easier reading). Most issues from Lukas have been added, these from Cordny have not been included yet. The list of issues will be deleted form the documentation before submission.

We then decided to go through the issues that are at the back of the specification document:

Issue 1
Frank suggests that claims should not be in specific format. Thomas this we should point to external documents (e.g. similarly to pointing out to SAML).

Issue 2
OAuth is silent about the types of claims.

Issue 6 & 7
These will be provided by the SMART team members. They will also provide concerete examples for the entire specification.

Cordny also discusses HTTP error messages, UMA error messages. Correct error messages need to be discussed and properly indicated what is handled where. Sometimes an error messages required HTTP success codes (and not error codes - for example an invalid token from a requester during validation request generates an HTTP success but itself uses an UMA error for the host).

Interface between UMA and trusted claims (OpenID Connect)

Domenico will discuss that more thoroughly during the next meeting and on the mailing list.

Next Meetings

Stay tuned for details of an ad hoc meeting before 23 Jun
WG telecon on Thursday, 23 Jun 2011, at 9-10:30am PT (time chart)
Stay tuned for details of an ad hoc meeting before 30 Jun
WG telecon on Thursday, 30 Jun 2011, at 9-10:30am PT (time chart)
- Skype line "C": +9900827042954214
- US: +1-201-793-9022 (other int'l numbers) | Room Code: 295-4214

Browser not supported