All Member Ballot - KIR20180403

This page reports on the details of the second All Member Ballot in 2018. We'll refer to it as All Member Ballot KIR20180403.


Motion: To approve the Group-Approved Recommendation as identified on this ballot as a Kantara Initiative Recommendation.

Document: SAML V2.0 Implementation Profile for Federation Interoperability
Version: 1.0
Document Date: 2018-03-08
Document URL: Download the document
Document wiki page:
WG Charter:

To see a summary of comments and changes made related to the public comment periods, see the disposition of comments.

Ballot Information

The prerequisites for this All-Member Ballot have been met:

Section 5.5 "Member Ballots of Work Group Recommendation" of the Kantara Initiative Bylaws and Article 6 "All-Member Ballot of a Draft Recommendation" of the Kantara Initiative Operating Procedures v2.0 require certification by a majority of Leadership Council voters that the draft Recommendation is ready for an All-Member Ballot, which means that:

-- The draft Recommendation are within the scope of the WG Charter;

-- That the required 45-day Public Review and Comment period has occurred;

-- Comments received have been reviewed by the WG, a disposition made and logged, the document draft updated accordingly;

-- A majority of the eligible Work Group voters have approved the draft Recommendation for approval via an All-Member Ballot.

Eligible Voters

All Members of Kantara Initiative may participate.

  • Each Member organization had the ability to cast only one vote.
  • The Primary Representative from each Member organization should have cast the Member's vote.

Approval Requirement: Super majority of those Voting, with at least 15% of all Members voting" (i.e. at least 75% of those casting a vote must vote to Approve).


This ballot was open from April 3, 2018 to April 17, 2018.

Ballot Results Summary

12 Members voted in this All Member Ballot; 11 voted YES; 0 voted NO; 1 ABSTAINED.

Ballot Results Details

1Digi.MeJulian RangerYES
2iWelcome B.V.Corné van RooijYES
4Cirrus IdentityDedra ChamberlinYES
5OTTO WG / GluuMichael SchwartzYES
6OpenConsentMark LizarYES
Andrew HughesYES
Walter HoehnYES
9CA TechnologiesDenny PrvuYES
10ForgeRockAllan FosterYES
Ken DaggYES
12Scott S. Perry CPA, PLLCScott PerryYES