All Member Ballot - KIR20100429
This page reports on the details of the first All Member Ballot of 2010. We'll refer to it as All Member Ballot KIR-20100429.
Motion
This is an All Member Ballot to approve the release of the following Draft Recommendation as a Kantara Initiative Recommendation.
Title of Draft Recommendation: Identity Assurance Framework Version 2.0
Copy of Draft Recommendation: http://bit.ly/iaf_member_ballot
This All-Member Ballot is open to all Members of Kantara Initiative.
- Each Member organization may cast only one vote.
- The Primary Representative from each Member organization should cast the organizational Member's vote.
- If you are unsure who your Primary Representative is please contact staff@kantarainitiative.org for assistance.
Approval of this All Member Ballot requires a "Supermajority of those Voting, with at least 15% of all Members voting" (i.e. at least 75% of those casting a vote must vote to Approve).
Duration
This ballot was open from April 9, 2010 until April 24, 23:59 UTC.
Ballot Results Summary
21 Member Representatives participated in the ballot. 20 voted Yes and 1 voted Abstain (comment provided for Abstain vote).
Ballot Results Details
- Results listed in the order they were received.
Â
Representative
Organization
Vote cast in favour
Comment
1
Alan Walsh
Indiana University
Yes
Â
2
Kyle Meadors
DGI
Yes
Â
3
Tatsuki Sakushima
NRI
Yes
Â
4
Lucy Lynch
Internet Society
Yes
Â
5
Robert Temple
BT
Yes
Â
6
Roger Sullivan
Oracle
Yes
Â
7
Ingo Friese
Deutsche Telekom
Yes
Â
8
Peter Davis
NeuStar
Yes
Â
9
Thomas Lowenhaupt
Global Patient Identifiers
Abstain
Not yet feeling fully qualified to vote y or n, I answer abstain here so as not to bog down the process by having less than 15% voting. If this has the opposite effect, as it can depending on by-laws, I will change the vote.
10
Colin Soutar
CSC
Yes
Â
11
John Tolbert
The Boeing Company
Yes
Â
12
Juergen Emhardt
Yes
Â
13
Atsuhiro Goto
NTT
Yes
Â
14
Colin Wallis
New Zealand Govt. DIA
Yes
Â
15
Leif Johansson
SUNET
Yes
Â
16
Frank Villavicencio
Identropy
Yes
Â
17
Andrew Nash
PayPal
Yes
Â
18
Barry Hieb
VUHID
Yes
Â
19
Mohammad Alam
Fraunhofer SIT
Yes
Â
20
Matthew Gardiner
CA
Yes
Â
21
John Fraser
MEDNETWorld
Yes
Â
References
This ballot was issued in compliance with section 6.2 and section 9 of the Operating Procedures.