All Member Ballot - KIR20100429

Motion

This is an All Member Ballot to approve the release of the following Draft Recommendation as a Kantara Initiative Recommendation.

Title of Draft Recommendation: Identity Assurance Framework Version 2.0
Copy of Draft Recommendation: http://bit.ly/iaf_member_ballot

This All-Member Ballot is open to all Members of Kantara Initiative.
- Each Member organization may cast only one vote.
- The Primary Representative from each Member organization should cast the organizational Member's vote.
- If you are unsure who your Primary Representative is please contact staff@kantarainitiative.org for assistance.

Approval of this All Member Ballot requires a "Supermajority of those Voting, with at least 15% of all Members voting" (i.e. at least 75% of those casting a vote must vote to Approve).

Duration

This ballot was open from April 9, 2010 until April 24, 23:59 UTC.

Ballot Results Summary

21 Member Representatives participated in the ballot.  20 voted Yes and 1 voted Abstain (comment provided for Abstain vote).

Ballot Results Details

• Results listed in the order they were received.

  	Representative	Organization	Vote cast in favour	Comment
  1	Alan Walsh	Indiana University	Yes
  2	Kyle Meadors	DGI	Yes
  3	Tatsuki Sakushima	NRI	Yes
  4	Lucy Lynch	Internet Society	Yes
  5	Robert Temple	BT	Yes
  6	Roger Sullivan	Oracle	Yes
  7	Ingo Friese	Deutsche Telekom	Yes
  8	Peter Davis	NeuStar	Yes
  9	Thomas Lowenhaupt	Global Patient Identifiers	Abstain	Not yet feeling fully qualified to vote y or n, I answer abstain here so as not to bog down the process by having less than 15% voting. If this has the opposite effect, as it can depending on by-laws, I will change the vote.
  10	Colin Soutar	CSC	Yes
  11	John Tolbert	The Boeing Company	Yes
  12	Juergen Emhardt		Yes
  13	Atsuhiro Goto	NTT	Yes
  14	Colin Wallis	New Zealand Govt. DIA	Yes
  15	Leif Johansson	SUNET	Yes
  16	Frank Villavicencio	Identropy	Yes
  17	Andrew Nash	PayPal	Yes
  18	Barry Hieb	VUHID	Yes
  19	Mohammad Alam	Fraunhofer SIT	Yes
  20	Matthew Gardiner	CA	Yes
  21	John Fraser	MEDNETWorld	Yes

References

This ballot was issued in compliance with section 6.2 and section 9 of the Operating Procedures.