P3-PFSG Meeting Notes 2011-03-31
Attendees:
Anna Slomovic
Mark Lizar
Gershon Janssen
Bill Braithwaite
John Bradley
Colin Wallis
Susan Landau
Peter Capek
Apologies:
Joni Brennan
Rich Furr
Staff:
Anna Ticktin
NOTES:
1. ADMINISTRATIVE
- Roll Call
2. PRIVACY FRAMEWORK DISCUSSION
Scope of Privacy Framework
- Question raised by IAF-1800: How does the IAF fit within a PF in terms of process and content for assessment criteria?
- Mark will be representing P3 on the LC-TF-SC call scheduled for 4 April 2011.
- ACTION ITEM 20110331-01 Mark — will suggest an agenda item for the LC-TF-SC to have wg leadership socialize their notion of where each group's work begins and ends.
Shared Health Care Use Case:
- Anna is concerned that the use case could drive the framework instead of vice versa.
- Bill suggests that there should be numerous use cases considered in order for the the trust framework to be all encompassing.
- ACTION ITEM 20110331-02 Bill Braithwaite: Find out more about the state of play in the health care use case and continue to act as a liaison on this issue.
- The group agrees to continue to build a more generic framework, until we have more direction on use cases focused on by Kantara.
- If this information is not received, then the group agrees to pick its own use case and build a profile from there.
Principles summaries to date:
- Use limitations will now include purpose specification.
- Members will be continuing their work on the remaining principles and will attempt to complete those efforts during the next week.
- The group discussed the latest work on choice structures and policy outcomes
- Opt-in / Opt-out structures
- Traditionally "opt-in" is privacy, "opt-out" is health care.
- Question: What direction does this group want to pursue?
PF next steps:
- Anna will send out some information so that the sub group may begin having substantive conversations around what the framework should look like.
3. AOB
- None