ULX Teleconference 2009-12-09
ULX Telecon 2009-12-09
Logistics
Date: Wednesday, 9 December 2009
Time: 16:00-17:00 Eastern
Skype: +9900827042954214
US Dial-In: +1-201-793-9022
Room Code: 295-4214
Attendees
Paul Trevithick
Debbie Bucci
Mike McIntosh
Mike Graves
Scott Cantor
Nate Klingenstein
Eve Maler
Gael Gourmelen
Philippe Clement
Benoit Bailleux
Joni Brennan
Valeska O'Leary
Trent Adams
RL "Bob" Morgan
Fulup Ar Foll
Regrets
Agenda
0) Roll Call
Quorum achieved.
1) Approve Minutes
Eve motions to approve, Nate seconds, no objection.
2) Is IDP Selection WG work in scope for ULX?
Please review these 5 slides and be prepared to discuss
Philippe: goes through slides for background on proposed work. Some differences in approach with ULX, some similarities.
Gael: MRD requirements (from slide 4):
SP delegates user selection of IdP to ISA
IdP discovery by ISA/user
IdP metadata acquisition by SP/ISA
GUI/UX guidelines for SP/ISA
Former Liberty IDPS group is now a running Kantara group, hence looking at more protocols etc.
Scott: pushing to merge the two groups, since member of both and IDS scope is subset of ULX scope
Bob: subset? seems like, eg, IdP metadata acquisition is out of scope for ULX
Scott: not necessarily
Paul: seems like this adds third case to ULX set: plain browser, browser-with-internal-agent, browser-with-cloud-agent - not that that's a bad thing ...
Paul: let's try to make a decision on this the next call
3) Non-chrome Login Button
Paul: reactions?
MG: use of FB Connect via RPX has quintupled in 60 days, so maybe "connect" verb is becoming more recognized
Fulup: French government uses "connection" for "login"; "login" is English-invented word
Bob: similarity to CardSpace v2 "pane" that invokes selector logic
MG: RPX component does lots of cool stuff
Paul: walk thru RPX on next call?
MG: sure
4) RP Metadata
MMc: describes work so far, XRD syntax is probably not right
Bob: mention of very similar concepts by Mozilla folks, ie "Account Manager Control Document"
Paul: u/p is a protocol too
Scott: XRD syntax changing yet again, so better to try to describe functionality than try for real XRD use
MMc: OK
5) Review Action Items
DONE: Paul to talk Mike McIntosh about starting a wiki page for RP metadata
DONE: Paul to talk to Valeska about creating a non-chrome login button
TBD: Bob to create a new use case by re-casting the European higher ed material
TBD: Paul to work with Valeska on getting first dynamic prototypes started