Weekly Meeting 2013 03 05 Notes
Information Sharing Work Group Teleconference
Date and Time
- Tuesday Mar 5 : 4:30 pm PDT, 7:30pm EDT
- Wednesday Mar 6 : 12:30am UK, 9:30am JT, 1:30pm NZT
- Please join my meeting via GoToMeeting
- Join the conference call
- Skype: +99051000000481
- US Dial-In: +1-805-309-2350
- UK Dial-In: +44-20-3137-5285
- Conference ID: 178-2540
- GoToMeeting ID: 844-771-298
Attendees
- Joe Andrieu
- Colin Wallis (non-voting)
- Lionel Klee (non-voting)
- Venkat Maddali (non-voting)
Apologies
Agenda
- Attendance
- Approval of Prior Minutes & Other Motions
- Prior Action Item Review
- Continuing Business
- Label Redesign
- New Business
- NSTIC
- Action Item Review
Minutes
1. Attendance
We noted that with 1 voting member in attendance, quorum was not met.
2. Motions
None
3. Prior Action Item Review
- Joe: Incorporate the NE Moves / Coldwell Banker label into the demo
- Joe: publish v.0.5 (sync with Demo)
- Joe: Compile use cases into a single doc
- Joe: Follow up with Valeska O'Leary DONE
4. Continuing Business
Label Redesign
Joe started work on a redesign effort, built on the insight that there are four parts to the label:
- the Recipient
- the Data
- the Data use & Management
- the Authorities
There's a new Google Doc for us to use as a sandbox for reimagining the label. Email joe@switchbook.com for an invite.
We reviewed the screenshots of the work that Lionel has been working on with RealMe at http://share.axure.com/NWNGLW/
Notably, it's more conversational on the left and they dropped revocation (it's not particularly appicable in their use case).
The item for "finding out more" combined a few items as well. Interestingly, they also have two labels on the same page because the data in the ceremony comes from two different places.
Venkat brought up the possibility of including the location for the data source. This wasn't relevant in the legacy work that the ISWG started from (because they weren't participants in the Sharing Agreement). However, it might be worth considering adding. Especially if we can do it without adding anything to the default view.
Venkat also shared the data model they are using for consent tokens in RealMe.
http://kantarainitiative.org/confluence/display/eGov/Privacy+Enhanced+WebSSO
We also discussed Nat Sakimura's blog about Pavlov's Internet dog... the dangers of training people to click "ok" every time. He suggested not only that we find a way for default terms to be accepted without the user asking, but also for icons to simplify the label.
Lionel and Colin agreed that the challenge with icons is that all by themselves they are rarely self-explanatory. But icons + text can be powerful. Joe mentioned that for Nutrition Labels, people hunt for specific things. Some hunt for fat grams, others calories or carbs, still others for particular ingredients. If an icon+text can capture common use cases, users hunting for particular terms will quickly learn the icon that they care about and be able to rely on the icon when reviewing the label.
With the new breakdown of the label into four components, it's clear that some of the terms may be amenable to icons, while others, like the Data Recipient, are not.
5. New Business
NSTIC
Joe has submitted a proposal to NSTIC on behalf of SwitchBook seeking funding for an Information Sharing Trust Framework based on the work of the ISWG. Proposals were due today. We'll find out about finalists April 19.
6. Action Items
- Joe: Incorporate the NE Moves / Coldwell Banker label into the demo
- Joe: publish v.0.5 (sync with Demo)
- Joe: Compile use cases into a single doc
- Joe: Follow up with Valeska O'Leary (Again)
Future To-Dos (so we don't lose them)
- Joe to write up Use Case discussion DONE
- Joe: Create an examples section on website and give Iain access
- Iain to publish latest standard label example to Kantara wiki, Joe to upload current version (label v 0.2)
- Joe: publish v.0.5
7. Next Meeting
60 minutes
- Tuesday Mar 12 : 12:30 pm PDT, 3:30pm EDT, 8:30pm UK
- Wednesday Feb 13: 5:30am JT, 8:30pm NZDT