Leadership Council Teleconference - 2010-03-31
Minutes approved April 28, 2010
Kantara Leadership Council Teleconference
Date and Time
- Date: Wednesday, March 31, 2010
- Time: 9am PST | 12pm EST | 16:00 UTC (Time Chart)
- Teleconference Options:
- Skype: +9900827043671716
- US Dial-In: +1-201-793-9022 | Room Code: 3671716
NOTES:
- Skype calls are toll-free, and you do NOT need to enter the Room Code.
- International Numbers: http://kantara.atlassian.net/wiki/display/GI/Telco+Bridge+Info
- Contact the Chair if you cannot use Skype and need a toll-free phone number (US or international)
Attendees
- Voting:
- User-Managed Access: Eve Maler
- ID-WSF Evolution: Paul Madsen
- Telecommunications Identity: Jonas Hogberg
- Consumer ID: Bob Pinheiro
- Privacy and Public Policy: Jeff Stollman (in place of Abbie)
- eGov: Colin Wallis
- Healthcare ID Assurance: John Fraser
- Liberty Spec Maintenance: Prateek Mishra
- Non-Voting:
- Concordia: Paul Madsen
- Staff: Joni Brennan
- Identity Community Update: J. Trent Adams
- Map the Gap: J. Trent Adams
- Staff: Roger Martin
Apologies
- None
Agenda
- Roll Call for Quorum Determination
- Approval of prior meeting minutes
- Action Items Review:
- Trent to notify Liberty Specification Maintenance WG and Identity Access Services WG they've been moved to non-voting status. (DONE)
- Trent and Roger Martin to discuss next steps in how to formalize the liaison proposal into practice. (In Progress)
- Trent and Roger Martin to discuss next steps in how to formalize the WG funding model into practice. (In Progress)
- Trent to recirculate the RSA presentations as a starting point. (DONE: rsa_201003_wg_slides.zip)
- The LC was asked by the BoT to help solicit volunteers from their organizations to join the Marketing Committee.
- Eve to spend some time drafting ideas that could be used to develop a process applied to triggering the deactivation of inactive groups.
- Trent to send announcement to LC list prompting attendance for the next teleconference, highlighting the steps required to move the IAWG work to an all-member ballot, stressing a need for speed.
- Frank will lead an effort to address a FAQ document that explains the various components of the ARB and how it relates to the OIX and GSA/ICAM.
- Trent to put this back on the LC agenda to make sure it's being addressed (DONE - albeit self-referentially)
- Request: IAWG asks the LC to run an all-member ballot looking for approval of their specifications.
- Review: http://kantara.atlassian.net/wiki/display/idassurance/WG+Approved+Specifications
- Kantara IAF-1000-Overview.pdf
- Kantara IAF-1100-Glossary.pdf
- Kantara IAF-1200-Levels of Assurance.pdf
- Kantara IAF-1300-Assurance Assessment Scheme.pdf
- Kantara IAF-1400-Service Assessment Criteria.pdf
- Kantara IAF-1600-Assessor Qualifications and Requirements.pdf
- Review: http://kantara.atlassian.net/wiki/display/idassurance/WG+Approved+Specifications
- Reallocation of staff to focus on organization activities (e.g. website and communication support)
- Reminder of Vacant Positions:
- LC Secretary
- LC Representative to the BoT
- AOB
Minutes
- Roll Call for Quorum Determination
- The Chair recognized the request by Prateek Mishra to regain voting status for Liberty Spec Maintenance WG.
- The number of LC voting members is updated to 15.
- The LC quorum requirement is updated to 8 (of 15).
- Quorum for the meeting is met with 8 of 15.
- Approval of prior meeting minutes
- MOTION: To accept the minutes as recorded for Leadership Council Teleconference - 2010-03-24.
- Moved by Colin, motion carried.
- Action Items Review:
- Trent to notify Liberty Specification Maintenance WG and Identity Access Services WG they've been moved to non-voting status.
- DONE
- Prateek responded and regained voting status for Liberty Spec Maintenance WG.
- Gavin responded and accepted non-voting status for Identity Access Services WG.
- Trent and Roger Martin to discuss next steps in how to formalize the liaison proposal into practice.
- In Progress
- Trent and Roger Martin to discuss next steps in how to formalize the WG funding model into practice.
- In Progress
- Trent to recirculate the RSA presentations as a starting point.
- The LC was asked by the BoT to help solicit volunteers from their organizations to join the Marketing Committee.
- Ongoing
- Contact Trent or KI Staff for participation details.
- Eve to spend some time drafting ideas that could be used to develop a process applied to triggering the deactivation of inactive groups.
- DONE
- Review: Email sent to the LC list
- Trent to send announcement to LC list prompting attendance for the next teleconference, highlighting the steps required to move the IAWG work to an all-member ballot, stressing a need for speed.
- DONE
- Frank will lead an effort to address a FAQ document that explains the various components of the ARB and how it relates to the OIX and GSA/ICAM.
- In Progress
- Joni, as KI Program Director, is working with Frank on this.
- Trent to put this back on the LC agenda to make sure it's being addressed
- DONE
- Suggestion to bring this topic to the Marketing Committee
- Trent to notify Liberty Specification Maintenance WG and Identity Access Services WG they've been moved to non-voting status.
- Request: IAWG asks the LC to run an all-member ballot looking for approval of their specifications.
- MOTION: To certify for an All Member Ballot the following set of documents approved by the Identity Assurance Work Group (IAWG) to be taken collectively as a Draft Recommendation to be known as the "Kantara Initiative Identity Assurance Framework (IAF) 2.0":
- John moved, Bob seconded
- Discussion:
- Trent: This is a procedural action, with the LC reviewing the steps taken by the IAWG in bringing the documents to an All-Member Ballot, but not evaluating the content of the documents themselves. The steps taken by the IAWG:
- produced and approved the listed documents
- publicized a 45-day public comment period
- reviewed the received comments
- created a "comments disposition" document describing responses to comments
- announced responses to comments for further public review
- receiving no further comments, asked the LC to certify process and hold an All-Member Ballot
- Joni passed along the comment from the IAWG appreciates the LC attention and understanding of the need for speed.
- John: Is this set of documents directly related to the GSA/ICAM Trust Frameworks project?
- Joni: These documents are not directly related to that project and is a separate track of activities, though once approved the documents will feed back into that track.
- Roger M: Congratulates the IAWG and the LC in producing the first ballot for an official Kantara Initiative Draft Recommendation.
- Trent: This is a procedural action, with the LC reviewing the steps taken by the IAWG in bringing the documents to an All-Member Ballot, but not evaluating the content of the documents themselves. The steps taken by the IAWG:
- Motion carried by unanimous consent
- Reallocation of staff to focus on organization activities (e.g. website and communication support)
- Joni and Dervla will no longer be available to take notes or action items on behalf of WG/DGs
- Groups needing assistance can contact Trent, Colin, or Roger M. to discuss options, but are asked not to contact Joni or Dervla directly
- Reminder of Vacant Positions:
- LC Secretary
- Trent has been acting LC Secretary, and is asking for assistance.
- There is likely to be additional work required of the LC Secretary with the new Liaison and Funding policies.
- Some activities such as the posting of the WG/DG quarterly reports have been de-prioritized for the time being.
- Suggested that if no one volunteers, the Chair impose a process to fill the Secretary position by rotating through the WG/DG chairs.
- LC Representative to the BoT
- The LC currently has only one representative to the BoT: Colin
- The position does include a full vote on the BoT for the LC representative.
- Anyone interested should contact Trent or Colin.
- LC Secretary
- Meeting adjourned at 17:02 UTC
Next Teleconference
- Date: Wednesday, April 14, 2010
- Time: 3pm PDT | 6pm EDT | 22:00 UTC (Time Chart)
- Teleconference Options:
- Skype: +9900827043671716
- US Dial-In: +1-201-793-9022 | Room Code: 3671716
NOTES:
- Skype calls are toll-free, and you do NOT need to enter the Room Code.
- International Numbers: http://kantara.atlassian.net/wiki/display/GI/Telco+Bridge+Info
- Contact the Chair if you cannot use Skype and need a toll-free phone number (US or international)