Meeting Minutes 21 August 2019
Kantara FI-WG Teleconference
Minutes approved on 04 September 2019 call
Date and Time
- Date: Wednesday, August 21, 2019
- Time: 16:30 EDT
Attendees
- Wessel, Keith (v)
- Bush, Judith (v)
- Cantor, Scott (v)
- Morgan, Andrew (v)
- Goodman, Eric
- Hoehn, Walter (v)
- Buxey, Alan (v)
- Wallis, Colin
Agenda
- Roll call (QV group participation agreement)
- Agenda bash
- Approval of 8/7 meeting minutes
- Walter: formatting revisions: completed and summarized in an 8/15 note to the mailing list. Outstanding questions/issues were:
- Nick’s AI to update the disposition column on the feedback page: https://kantarainitiative.org/confluence/x/6IDJBg
- Rainer provided clarification on his feedback on SDP-SP23 in an email to the list dated 27 July. Any action to be taken?
- Review of outstanding issues in Github
- Any further work needed on feedback received so far
Minutes
- Roll call (QV group participation agreement)
- Quorum achieved
- We will remove John Bradley from the list
- Agenda bash
- Should "SAML Browser SSO Profile" and "Single Logout profiles" in the "Notations and Terminology" section have references?
- In section 1, there is a reference, but in section 1.1, there is not a reference.
- Should it say “Web Browser SSO Profile” everywhere? There is inconsistency in the naming and capitalization
- Capitalize “Profile”
- Web Browser SSO Profile/Single Logout Profile
- SAML Browser or Browser => Web Browser
- Minutes approved
- Approval of 8/7 meeting minutes
- Walter: formatting revisions: completed and summarized in an 8/15 note to the mailing list. Outstanding questions/issues were:
AI: Eric will review for consistency
- Should the abstract or introduction mention that this document supersedes saml2int, since the title has changed with this version?
- Proposed that we remove the subsection numbers, but otherwise keep the content unchanged.
- Alan suggests making them section headings instead of numbers
- Just remove subheadings from 2.1. AI Alan wrote PR.
- This working group could say that this supersedes the prior version, provided the Kantara leadership doesn’t disagree.
- REFEDS uses the original document and probably can’t use the new version
- Path of least resistance is to leave as-is rather than try to explain why
- Decision: leave this as-is
- What about saml2int.org? Do nothing now
- In section 2.1 all four requirements have their own subsections. This seems a bit inconsistent with later sections.
AI: Walter merge(d) the existing pull request (DONE)
- There is still an asciidoctor artifact that is causing the "Contributors" headings to be red. I/we should probably figure that out, although I guess it looks fine as is.
AI: Alan wants to beat on this for a while to try to make it match the implementation profile (DONE)
- Walter - reading through the whole document - the requirements seem like they have received considerable word-smithing, but the introduction and another section could use some touch-up. AI: Walter will send improved wording to the list for review
- Nick’s AI to update the disposition column on the feedback page: https://kantarainitiative.org/confluence/x/6IDJBg
- Scott completed revisions to items 5 and 6. Any further work needed on this page?
- Homework assignment for everyone - review the disposition column. Is there anything else to be done for these items? Issue 6 may need improvement.
- Rainer provided clarification on his feedback on SDP-SP23 in an email to the list dated 27 July. Any action to be taken?
- “Responding to item 4 (SDP-SP23/IDP-disco): I agree that [IdPDisco] does not prescribe the caching solution. However, it fails to point out that best practice is to have a centralized caching solution but decentralized UI. At least I think that this is best practice, because it reduces the IDP-disco process, and in certain use cases (users always starting with an intranet portal that will provision IDP-disco cookies upfront) it can almost eliminate it. The RA21-document that I mentioned describes this approach.”
- Related to homework item above.
- Here is Rainer’s clarification:
- Scott disagrees that centralized discovery is a best practice
- Scott - our document should be silent about this. Eric agrees.
- We (Shib project?) tried to separate the discovery from the SP so that changes to discovery don’t require changes to the SP software.
- Deep linking matters
- Review of outstanding issues in Github
- Any further work needed on feedback received so far
Next Meeting
- Date: Weds, Sep 4, 2019
- Time: 16:30 EDT
- Code: https://global.gotomeeting.com/join/110596309
You can also dial in using your phone.
United States: +1 (669) 224-3318
Access Code: 110-596-309
More phone numbers
Australia: +61 2 8355 1038
Austria: +43 1 2530 22500
Belgium: +32 28 93 7002
Canada: +1 (647) 497-9380
Denmark: +45 32 72 03 69
Finland: +358 923 17 0556
France: +33 170 950 590
Germany: +49 692 5736 7300
Ireland: +353 15 360 756
Italy: +39 0 230 57 81 80
Netherlands: +31 207 941 375
New Zealand: +64 9 282 9510
Norway: +47 21 93 37 37
Spain: +34 932 75 1230
Sweden: +46 853 527 818
Switzerland: +41 225 4599 60
United Kingdom: +44 330 221 0097
NOTE: Do not follow the code with a "#" symbol as it may cause the code not to be recognized.