Leadership Council Teleconference - 2009-06-24
Kantara Leadership Council Teleconference
Date and Time
Date: Wednesday, June 24, 2009
Time: 3pm PDT | 6pm EDT | 22:00 UTC (Time Chart)
Dial-In: +1-218-862-7200
Code: 896272
NOTE: Do not follow the code with a "#" symbol as it may cause the code not to be recognized.
Attendees
J. Trent Adams (Chair)
Matthew Gardiner
Kenji Takahashi
Joni Brennan (staff)
Myisha Frazier-Mcelveen
Eve Maler (Secretary)
Ken Salzberg
Conor Cahill
Britta Glade (staff)
Bob Pinheiro
John Fraser
Brett McDowell (staff)
Paul Madsen (Vice-Chair)
Robin Wilton
Colin Wallis
Apologies
Dervla O'Reilly
Agenda
Approval of prior meeting minutes
Please review: Leadership Council Teleconference - 2009-06-17
WG / DG Updates:
WG Approved: Identity Provider Selection Work Group (IdP Selection WG)
Activation and provisioning update [KI Staff]
Progress Update: Privacy and Public Policy Work Group (P3WG)
Vote begins via email Wednesday, June 24
Vote closes at 23:59 UTC on Friday, June 26
Progress Update: Japan Work Group (Japan WG)
Need to vote on charter ASAP (on this call?)
Progress Update: Consumer Identity WG (CIWG)
Preliminary feedback review.
Need to set date for vote [Trent]
For Review: ID-Web Services Framework (ID-WSF) Work Group
Accepted on June 23, 2009
Discussion
Need to set date for vote [Trent]
Other WG/DG Updates?
WG / DG Participation Application Form Update [Brett]
Board of Trustees Update [Colin, Conor]
Event Task Force Update [Britta on behalf of Dervla]
Need WG/DG chair input on possible meeting time
LC Policy Discussions:
Email Policy Update [Trent]
Please Review: Groups Email Discussion List Policy
Recording Policy Update [Trent]
Proposal: Formation of general Policy Task Force [Trent]
FYI: Next Marketing call planned for July 7th - focused on the proposed marketing audience.
AOB
Minutes
Approval of prior meeting minutes
Please review: Leadership Council Teleconference - 2009-06-17
Minutes APPROVED by unanimous consent
WG / DG Updates:
WG Approved: Identity Provider Selection Work Group (IdP Selection WG)
Activation and provisioning update [KI Staff]
Approved by email vote as of last week.
Provisioning status is "go". The WG mail list has been created, and the group participation form is in place.
More is being done to clarify the provisioning and startup flow to new participants.
Progress Update: Privacy and Public Policy Work Group (P3WG)
Vote begins via email Wednesday, June 24
Vote closes at 23:59 UTC on Friday, June 26
The call for votes for this WG will be issued today, closing on Friday.
The WG chair has received helpful input inside and outside the LC calls, and welcomes additional input.
Progress Update: Japan Work Group (Japan WG)
Need to vote on charter ASAP (on this call?)
A question was raised about why other country groups were not listed as potential liaisons; it was suggested to add a generic statement about liaising with other regional groups as appropriate.
The charter was amended on the site during the call to add, in Section 10, "Liaison with other Regional Work and Discussion Groups."
It was noted that the WG currently has an informal relationship with OpenID Foundation Japan, not currently mentioned explicitly, and anticipates having a more formal relationship later.
Motion to approve the Japan WG charter as amended APPROVED by unanimous consent.
AI: KI staff to create, provision, and announce the group.
Progress Update: Consumer Identity WG (CIWG)
Preliminary feedback review.
Need to set date for vote [Trent]
It was suggested that the groups focusing on consumer identity and healthcare have liaison opportunities.
The assumption made about the online focus on consumer activity was questioned; offline processes such as identity proofing and asynchronous/out-of-band processes such as using cell phones as part of authentication are not being focused on for now.
The chosen Liberty option for IPR was discussed, in the context of the group's intent to produce (and desire to claim ownership of) white papers.
It was suggested to get a legal person onto a future call to explain the subtleties of IPR options.
No vote was scheduled quite yet.
For Review: ID-Web Services Framework (ID-WSF) Work Group
Accepted on June 23, 2009
Discussion
Need to set date for vote [Trent]
It was asked whether other draft technical specs need to be listed. The group anticipates facilitating the simple transfer of the original ID-WSF V2.0 specs to another home, not revising those original specs.
OASIS and IETF are the likely two bodies where specs will be submitted; the suggestion to join-up the listings of specs and standards-setting organizations more closely.
The idea of developing a "consent service" in this WG was brought up; the underlying technical basis of such an effort would be the biggest factor in determining a home for it in Kantara.
The "continue the development" language was questioned, since it may imply more active new development than is intended.
AI: Trent to set up a voting schedule with the WG chair.
Other WG/DG Updates?
The Healthcare SIG has been developing a proposed charter.
The Concordia DG proposed charter has been submitted for acceptance-review. The LC Secretary has recused herself from this review, which will be taken up by the other LC officers shortly.
WG / DG Participation Application Form Update [Brett]
A working participation form has been approved because of the pressure of several groups waiting to get going. A revision, with various optimizations, is waiting for legal review.
Board of Trustees Update [Colin, Conor]
Event Task Force Update [Britta on behalf of Dervla]
Need WG/DG chair input on possible meeting time
ELFEL has an event Sep 30-Oct 1, and could work with us on holding a meeting there.
We are locked into DIDW for our first big F2F meeting. We have three rooms, accommodating 20 people each, on the Monday through the Wednesday.
A funding model is in the works for possibly holding a public RSA-style workshop, likely on the Monday.
It was suggested that the LC get more involved in crafting the DIDW Kantara event planning.
LC Policy Discussions:
Email Policy Update [Trent]
Please Review: Groups Email Discussion List Policy
Please review the draft linked from today's agenda. Trent will send a separate plea for review in email.
Recording Policy Update [Trent]
Proposal: Formation of general Policy Task Force [Trent]
FYI: Next Marketing call planned for July 7th - focused on the proposed marketing audience.
AOB
The BoT had a concern about requiring non-US people to pay high international tolls using the current telecon system. Kantara is therefore going to sponsor a premium bridge, for use with selected telecons, that allows for high-def conferencing that will interface with Skype.
The organization is also soliciting offers from participants to host calls.
Teleconference Recording
Recording not being made during this call, per prior request.
Next Meeting
Date: Wednesday, July 1, 2009
Time: 8am PDT | 11am EDT | 15:00 UTC (Time Chart)
Dial-In: +1-218-862-7200
Code: 896272
NOTE: Do not follow the code with a "#" symbol as it may cause the code not to be recognized.